health news arrowHome >> Medical Ethics >> AMA Opposes Policy That Would Presume Patients' Wishes Mon, 23 Nov 2009 GMT 
health news
  NEWS YOU CAN TRUST

Search Health News 
Browser Preferences
 Add to Favorites

Main Menu
 Home
 - - - - - Hot Topics - - - - -
 Bird Flu
 Drug Safety
 Stem Cell Research
 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
 Alternative Medicine
 Children's Health
 Diet & Nutrition
 Disabilities
 *Diseases & Conditions
 Drugs & Herbs
 Environmental Health
 Fitness & Exercise
 Genetic Research
 Health Insurance
 Medical Ethics
 Men's Health
 *Mental Illness
 Pain
 Parenting
 Public Health & Safety
 Senior Care
 *Sexual Health
 Women's Health
 World Health
 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
 Web Links
 Contact Us: info@dailynewscentral.com

XML News Feeds


 

HEALTH NEWS

AMA Opposes Policy That Would Presume Patients' Wishes

PDF  Print  E-mail
 22 June, 2005  18:20 GMT

The American Medical Association on Tuesday adopted a policy opposing any legislation that presumes patients would want life-sustaining treatment unless they have clearly stated otherwise.

The policy came in response to the Terri Schiavo case. Many attending the annual meeting of the nation's largest physicians group said Schiavo's fate should have remained a matter decided by her family and her doctors.

The Florida woman died in March after her feeding tube was disconnected following a long, highly publicized court battle between her husband and parents over whether she would have wanted to be kept alive.

Doctor-Patient Issues

Several states are considering or have passed laws that presume patients would want life-sustaining treatment, said Dr. Michael Williams, a Johns Hopkins Hospital neurologist who helped sponsor the measure.

"While the [Schiavo] circumstances were heart-wrenching and compelling, they're so rare that they're not a good basis to revise existing law," Williams said. "I wish there had not been politics involved in it, and I hope there won't be in the future should similar cases arise."

Tuesday's action also reaffirmed existing AMA policy that says it is ethical in some cases to discontinue life-sustaining treatment if it is in the patient's best interests.

Existing AMA policy did not help Schiavo and "did not help the courts and Congress keep their noses out" of doctor-patient issues, Dr. Arvind Goyal told AMA delegates Tuesday.

End-of-Life Wishes

Schiavo collapsed in 1990 after a chemical imbalance caused her heart to stop. She left no written instructions in the event she became disabled, and her husband said she never would have wanted to be kept alive in what court-appointed doctors called a persistent vegetative state with no hope of recovery.

Her parents, however, doubted she had any such end-of-life wishes. They maintained she would benefit from rehabilitation, despite most doctors saying her condition was irreversible.

AMA Trustee Dr. John Armstrong said the case underscores the importance of patients making their end-of-life wishes known while they are still healthy, through living wills or advanced directives.




Related Articles
Schiavo Case Upside: More People May Make Dying Wishes Clear (24 Mar 2005)
The Time for End-of-Life Decisions: Now (27 Mar 2005)
Heart-Disease Prevention Begins in the Womb (12 Oct 2004)
Politics Has a Place in Schiavo Debate (19 Mar 2005)
Baby's First Week May Set Lifelong Weight Patterns (19 Apr 2005)
Court Rules Doctors Have Right to Let Baby Charlotte Die (27 Feb 2006)
 
Sponsored Text Links
Hydroderm: Lose wrinkles with Hydroderm
InsureMe.com: Click here to get a free health insurance quote.
SkinStore.com: StriVectin-SD
Hydroderm: Body Shape - Proven to be safe and effective - Free Trial!
SkinStore.com: Strivectin SD 6oz Best Price Offer